Sunday, 29 April 2012

Dividend vs shareholder wealth in the banking sector


The debate on bonus awards whilst dividend payments are low is increasing especially in the banking sector.  Banks saw shares decline throughout 2011 as the table below shows

Citigroup’s shares halved last year yet they paid their chief executive, Vikram Pandit $15m even though the Federal Reserve did not allow Citigroup to return capital to its shareholders.  It was also thought that Mr Pandit’s pay was highly unrestricted due to the lack of aims and incentives to increase shareholder value (Telegraph, 18 April 2012).  Barclays has been hit just this week with what is thought to be one of the worst shareholder rebellions, as nearly one third of investors would not agree to pay deals for senior executives (Telegraph: BBC News, 27 April 2012).  Investors do not approve of the way Barclays measures targets by using return on equity as this figure can be increased easily by leveraging up, and investors feel this could be dangerous to the company (BBC News, 20 April 2012).

Companies can create value for shareholders in many ways, mainly through mergers and acquisitions or reinvestment into positive NPV projects.  Wilbur (1932) suggests there are four factors which should determine dividend policy;

   1.Confidence actual earnings will be measured
   2. Likelihood of unfavourable developments
   3. How well unforeseen emergencies can be provided for
   4. How much could be advantageously reinvested

Dividends are influenced by investment and financing decisions.  They are paid out of realised profit and can relate to previous year’s profit, not necessarily paid from current year realised profit.  Though loan agreements can limit how much dividends can be paid.  But whether a company pay a dividend or not, different views can be taken, informational context of dividends.  Paying a dividend would usually be seen as positive as it would seem the company have good finances.  However Modigliani and Miller suggest it can be a sign that the company do not have any better way to utilise the money.  They feel reinvestment is more important to improve shareholder wealth.  They argue dividends are part of the investment process.   Therefore money should be used for positive NPV projects and only left over profit should be paid to shareholders as a dividend.  If high dividends are paid it can indicate that there may be low future prospects as there is lack of reinvestment.  Therefore to avoid misjudgement and possible negative implications to share price the company must communicate their reasons clearly to shareholders. Donaldson (1956) suggests that the pecking order theory.  He says that dividends should always be paid even if it means borrowing money.  

The problem arising for banks is that share prices are dropping, dividends are low but salaries and bonuses are high.  The worry for shareholders is why the substantial amount of money being paid in bonuses is not utilised in the company better through reinvestment or other options which would increase shareholder wealth.  Banks do not currently appear to be acting in the interest of shareholders. Therefore as Modigliani and Miller suggest shareholders are wondering if the banks see no other ways to improve shareholder value, and the Federal Reserve are increasing the problem for citigroup by blocking dividend payments.  Communication is key to ensuring shareholders understand the reasons behind financial decisions made and after Barclays had announced its reasons for executive pay the share price increased by 10.75p (http://www.stockmarketwire.com : http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business/market_data/shares/3/87068/one_month.stm).

Above: Barclays share price change between March and May 2012


Wilbur, E. (1932) ‘A study of the policy of dividend stabilization’, Harvard Business Review, 10(3) pp. 373-381. Business Source Premier, EBSOhost [Online] (Accessed: 29 April 2012).

1 comment:

  1. You have good articles here! If anyone here is looking for a loan @ 2% rate in return to buy a home or other financing needs, I want you to contact Mr Pedro On pedroloanss@gmail.com When I was introduced to Mr. Pedro at the market watch seminar, I was entering the market as a first time buyer. Naturally,my needs were a bit different and I had loads of questions. Before he sent me my pre-approval letter, he called to speak with me about what it meant and what could change. He made himself available to me at pretty much any hour via email and texts. He was very responsive and knowledgeable. He’s also very straightforward. I explained to him what my expectations were in terms of closing time and other particulars. He said he would meet those expectations but he surpassed them. I closed so quickly my realtor and the seller of course were excited about that. But as a buyer I appreciated being walked through the process of Mr Pedro loan offer. From pre-approval to closing- the journey was so seamless and I consider myself lucky because I’ve heard horror stories. I recommend him to anyone looking for a loan. Everything was handled electronically expediently and securely   

    ReplyDelete